Blog Elements : IFR Focus

What would you do if an engine problem developed in actual IMC but the nearest airport wasn’t necessarily your safest option?

That’s the dilemma in this month’s IFR Mastery scenario from PilotWorkshops, The End Is Niagara?, featuring instructor Martin Pauly.

You’re flying your RV-14 with your new spouse toward Niagara Falls when the engine suddenly begins running rough in IMC. One cylinder’s EGT and CHT are dropping rapidly, and your troubleshooting attempts don’t solve the problem. The nearest airport is only 10 miles away, but the instrument approach could leave you below glide range over hilly terrain. Better weather and potentially better options lie farther ahead.

Where would you go?

Watch the free scenario briefing below and make your decision.

There isn’t always one “right” answer

One of the most valuable aspects of instrument flying is learning to recognize the tradeoffs behind every decision. Often, the challenge isn’t knowing how to fly an approach—it’s deciding which approach offers the greatest margin of safety given the conditions.

That’s exactly what IFR Mastery is designed to develop. Each month, PilotWorkshops presents a new real-world IFR scenario that puts you in the pilot’s seat. You’ll evaluate the situation, make your decision, and then—inside the full program—compare your thinking with experienced instructors as they explain the factors that influenced their choice.

Think you’ve made the right call?

Watch the free scenario briefing above, then start a free 30-day trial to access the complete scenario, instructor analysis, and the complete library of VFR and IFR Mastery scenarios.

Professional Preparation for Single-Pilot IFR in Busy Airspace

The phone call came from a recently instrument-rated Cirrus pilot sitting at a busy Class B airport with the engine running. He had received his IFR clearance, but he did not understand what Air Traffic Control had given him. The frequency was busy, the FBO line person was watching and waiting patiently to marshal him out of parking, and the pressure he felt was increasing by the minute.

His problem was not that he could not fly an instrument approach. He had recently demonstrated that skill well enough to earn an instrument rating. His problem was that he had never experienced an operation like this.

The FAA’s Instrument Airplane Airman Certification Standards establish the knowledge and skills required for certification, but no practical test can reproduce every environment a pilot may encounter afterward. Although the ACS requires knowledge of Standard Instrument Departures (SIDs), Standard Terminal Arrival Routes (STARs), climb gradients, and associated constraints, the practical test does not specifically require an applicant to fly an actual SID or STAR or demonstrate the “climb via” and “descend via” clearances that commonly accompany them. Nor does it require operations at busy Class B or Class C airports where these procedures are routine.

Busy airspace is not the place to learn those functions for the first time.

Nevertheless, after earning an instrument rating, a pilot may legally depart Atlanta, arrive at Dallas/Fort Worth, or fly into Chicago O’Hare. The pilot in my opening story was qualified, but he had not yet developed the operational experience necessary to manage that environment comfortably.

In Part 121 operations, complex environments are managed through standardization, preparation, defined procedures, and shared cockpit responsibilities. A single pilot does not have another crewmember available to catch an error or absorb part of the workload, but many of the same professional habits can be adapted to the Part 91 cockpit. The objective is to anticipate workload before it arrives.

The objective is to anticipate workload before it arrives.

Prepare Before Engine Start

Professional pilots do not wait for the cockpit to become busy before preparing. If departing a large airport, review the likely runway and SID before contacting Clearance Delivery. Understand the routing, altitude restrictions, climb gradient, navigation requirements, and what a “climb via” clearance will require.

Consider using services that provide Pre-Departure Clearance (PDC) and digital ATIS when available through a compatible avionics or electronic flight bag provider. Receiving the clearance and D-ATIS electronically allows time to review the routing, study the SID, and program the Flight Management System before starting the engine. The objective is not merely convenience. It is reducing workload before the airplane begins moving.

If a clearance received via PDC or radio does not make sense, ask ATC to clarify it. Do not allow embarrassment or concern about occupying the frequency to turn uncertainty into an incorrect clearance. Controllers would rather clarify or repeat an instruction than have a pilot misunderstand it.

Avionics proficiency is equally important. Modern FMS and GPS navigators make complex procedures manageable—but only when the pilot understands how to use them. Before operating in busy terminal airspace, become proficient at loading and modifying SIDs, STARs, transitions, and approaches. Busy airspace is not the place to learn those functions for the first time.

One common trap involves STARs that divide into runway-specific segments. When loading the arrival, the navigator may require selection of the expected landing runway. Without that selection, the route may end near the waypoint where the STAR branches rather than continue along the appropriate runway transition. Understand how the installed avionics handle these procedures before encountering them under time pressure.

Use Cruise Time Wisely

Professional pilots rarely regard cruise as the boring part of a flight. It is valuable preparation time.

Obtain the destination weather and ATIS early enough to complete arrival planning before beginning the descent. Review the expected STAR, including its altitude and airspeed restrictions, and prepare the most likely approach. If more than one runway or approach appears likely, identify an alternate rather than waiting for a change from ATC.

Even when expecting a visual approach, load and brief an appropriate instrument approach as a backup—preferably one with vertical guidance. Resist the temptation to load a GPS-generated visual approach if your navigator offers that option. At many busy airports, controllers expect aircraft to navigate to the Final Approach Fix associated with the published ILS or RNAV approach because that is where speed restrictions and sequencing are often built into the arrival. Airline crews are generally required to have an instrument approach loaded in the FMS even when cleared for a visual approach, so ATC may issue instructions referencing that procedure. Loading the corresponding instrument approach improves situational awareness, supports those instructions, provides a stabilized vertical path, and reduces the chance of landing at the wrong airport or runway.

Loading a procedure is only the first step. Verify that you’ve selected the correct runway and transition, then compare the programmed flight plan with the current published chart. Confirm the lateral routing, altitude constraints, airspeed restrictions, and missed approach procedure. In a two-pilot flight deck, both crewmembers independently verify the programming. A single pilot doesn’t have that second set of eyes, making an unhurried chart-to-screen comparison even more important.

The briefing should be concise and useful. Rather than reading the chart aloud, brief the applicable minimums and enter them into your avionics if that capability is available. Then concentrate on what is unusual or most likely to cause an error: localizer frequency identification and setup, a difficult crossing restriction, terrain, an offset final, parallel runways, a complicated missed approach, runway conditions, or the possibility of a late runway change.

The purpose of a briefing is not to prove that you can read the chart. It is to identify threats before they demand your attention, verify that the waypoints loaded in the FMS match the current chart, and confirm that the correct approach minimums have been entered.

Know When to Say “Unable”

ATC clearances are designed to maintain an efficient traffic flow, but controllers cannot know every aircraft’s limitations. STARs serving airline hubs may contain speeds around 290 knots to sequence transport-category airplanes. That may exceed the operating limitations of many smaller general aviation aircraft.

If your aircraft cannot comply, advise ATC promptly: “Unable the 290 knots.” The same principle applies to climb gradients, descent rates, crossing restrictions, or any other clearance beyond the capabilities of the aircraft or pilot.

“Unable” is not a sign of weakness. It is useful information and a sign of sound judgment.

If an unexpected change requires additional programming, tell ATC that you need time. A request for extended vectors or additional track miles is preferable to hurried button-pushing while the airplane continues toward the terminal area. If necessary, request holding until the new procedure can be loaded, briefed, and verified.

ATC controls the sequence, but the pilot still controls whether the airplane is ready to proceed.

“Unable” is not a sign of weakness. It is useful information and a sign of sound judgment.

Do Not Forget the Airport

Ground operations deserve the same preparation as the flight itself. Many instrument training flights take place at airports with relatively simple taxiway layouts. At large Class B airports, however, taxiways often have two-letter identifiers. At Dallas/Fort Worth, for example, a clearance might include Taxiways EM or EL. To a pilot encountering those names for the first time, the instructions may sound like a rapid string of unrelated letters.

Have the airport diagram open before the airplane moves. Review hotspots, anticipate the likely taxi route, and write down lengthy instructions. If uncertain, stop the aircraft and ask Ground Control for clarification.

Arrival planning should continue through landing and taxi. Before touchdown, anticipate the likely runway exit and know the general direction of parking. This is not the time to be asking yourself, “Do I turn off to the right or left?” At a large airport, the workload does not end when the wheels touch the runway.

Creating Time

Busy airspace is not challenging merely because controllers talk quickly or airports are large. It is challenging because several high-workload tasks can occur simultaneously, and ATC generally expects pilots to understand and promptly comply with the clearances they accept.

The pilot who first begins thinking about the arrival after top of descent will probably feel rushed. The pilot who has already reviewed the STAR, prepared an alternate approach, verified the avionics, briefed the threats, opened the airport diagram, and considered the taxi route will often find the same operation surprisingly manageable.

The objective is not to make a personal airplane operate like an airliner. It is to borrow the professional habits that allow airline crews to manage complex operations safely and efficiently.

Busy airspace rewards preparation and exposes its absence. Review the procedures early, understand the capabilities of your avionics and aircraft, brief the threats, and create additional time whenever the operation begins moving faster than you can safely manage it.

The frequency may be busy, but the cockpit does not have to be. Staying ahead of the airplane begins long before the controller starts talking quickly.

Half Sized Blog Element (Single Author Style)

Half Sized Blog Element (Multi Author Style)

New IFR Mastery Scenario:The End Is Niagara?

Before the Frequency Gets Busy

New IFR Mastery Scenario:The End Is Niagara?

Before the Frequency Gets Busy

Full Sized Blog Element (Big Preview Pic)

New IFR Mastery Scenario:The End Is Niagara?

There isn’t always one “right” answer

Before the Frequency Gets Busy

Professional Preparation for Single-Pilot IFR in Busy Airspace

Prepare Before Engine Start

Use Cruise Time Wisely

Know When to Say “Unable”

Do Not Forget the Airport

Creating Time

Email Subscription

Recent Articles